Skip to main content

Table 1 Outcome definitions and evaluations

From: Intertruncal versus classical approach to the ultrasound-guided supraclavicular brachial plexus block for upper extremity surgery: study protocol for a randomized non-inferiority trial

 

Definition

Evaluation

Primary outcome

 

 The percentages of patients with a complete sensory blockade at 20 min

The combined score is equal to or greater than 7 points.

The sensory blockade of the 4 terminal branches of the brachial plexus is evaluated and graded every 5 min until 30 min after injection using a validated 3-point scale*.

Most important secondary outcomes

 

 Nerve injury

The percentages of patients who have been associated with persistent paresthesia or weak of the operative upper limb.

7 days after surgery via post-operation follow-up at the ward or telephone follow-up.

 Incidence of adverse events

The percentages of patients who have been occurred with vascular puncture, Horner syndrome, toxicity of LA, or pneumothorax.

According to drawing with blood, real-time ultrasonic image, and (or) the patient’s symptoms. A detailed description is seen in the footnote£.

 Diaphragmatic paralysis

The excursion of the ipsilateral hemidiaphragm will be measured by ultrasound in supine position via the anterior subcostal route in centimeters.

Using ultrasonic evaluation at 35 min after injection.

Other secondary outcomes

 

 Imaging time

Defined as the time from initial contact of the ultrasound probe with the skin until obtaining satisfactory imaging.

A stopwatch to calculate

 Needle time

Defined as the time from initial needle insertion until the complete injection of the LA.

A stopwatch to calculate

 Performance time

Defined as the imaging time plus the needle time.

/

 Satisfactory imaging

Defined as more than 4 divisions of the plexus should be visualized as hypoechoic circular structures lateral to the subclavian artery for the CA-SB, and all 3 trunks of the plexus (upper, middle, and lower) for IA-SB.

Real-time ultrasonic image

 Needle pass

Defined as at least 10-mm withdrawal of the needle to retract its trajectory.

During puncture

 Needle visual score

Converted into a 5-point scale§

Assessment will be made at the time when the first proper position for LA injection is confirmed.

 Procedural-related pain

Converted into the numeric rating scale (NRS)

NRS: 0 = no pain, 10 = worst possible pain

 Difficult level

Converted into the NRS

NRS: 0 = no difficulty, 10 = extremely difficulty

 Surgical anesthesia

Defined as one can tolerate surgical stimulus

During skin incision

 The percentages of patients with a complete sensory or motor blockade

The combined score is equal to or greater than 7 points.

The percentages of patients with complete sensory or motor blockade using a validated 3-point scale# every 5 min until 30 min after injection.

 Sensory onset time

The time point when combined score is equal to or greater than 7 points.

Using a validated 3-point scale every 5 min until 30 min after injection.

 Motor onset time

The time point when combined score is equal to or greater than 7 points.

Using a validated 3-point scale every 5 min until 30 min after injection.

 Sensory-motor onset time

The time point when the combined score is equal to or greater than 14 points.

Using a validated 3-point scale for complete sensory-motor blockade every 5 min until 30 min after injection.

 Duration of the sensory-motor blockade

Converted into the NRS

0 = normal compare that to the contralateral upper limb, 10 = no feeling or complete in-mobility; sensory-motor blockade return to normal will be defined as NRS<3.

  1. *3-point scale for sensory blockade: 0 = no block, 1 = partial anesthesia, 2 = complete anesthesia
  2. £Vascular puncture is defined as the needle is placed at the optimal location and withdraws with blood before injection under ultrasound guidance. Horner syndrome consisted of the occurrence of symptoms of miosis, ptosis, and hyperemia observed by anesthesiologists within 30 min after injection. Toxicity of LA consisted of the occurrence of signs of agitated, paresthesia, tinnitus, vertigo and perioral numbness, and convulsions, etc., due to central nervous system toxicity observed by anesthesiologists within 30 min after injection. Pneumothorax will be assessed by chest X-ray when the needle accidentally punctures the pleura during performing the block, or the patient feels ipsilateral chest pain, and/or is accompanied by symptoms of severe chest tightness or dyspnea
  3. §5-point scale for needle visual score: 1 = very poor, 2 = poor, 3 = fair, 4 = good, and 5 = very good
  4. #3-point scale for motor blockade: 0 = no block, 1 = paresis, and 2 = paralysis