The efficacy of polyglycolic acid felt reinforcement in preventing postoperative pancreatic fistula after pancreaticojejunostomy in patients with main pancreatic duct less than 3 mm in diameter and soft pancreas undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy (PLANET-PJ trial): study protocol for a multicentre randomized phase III trial in Japan and Korea

Peer Review reports

Original Submission
26 Nov 2018	Submitted	Original manuscript
28 Feb 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Pascal Probst
6 Mar 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Georgios Polychronidis
6 Mar 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Jean Marc Regimbeau
12 Mar 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Helen Mossop
13 Mar 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Thomas Pausch
16 Mar 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Aude Merdrignac
15 Apr 2019	Author responded	Author comments - Kazuto Shibuya
Resubmission - Version 2
15 Apr 2019	Submitted	Manuscript version 2
24 Apr 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Thomas Pausch
25 Apr 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Pascal Probst
28 Apr 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Helen Mossop
29 Apr 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Jean Marc Regimbeau
1 May 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Georgios Polychronidis
4 May 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Aude Merdrignac
31 May 2019	Author responded	Author comments - Kazuto Shibuya
Resubmission - Version 3
31 May 2019	Submitted	Manuscript version 3
5 Jun 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Pascal Probst
7 Jun 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Georgios Polychronidis
10 Jun 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Thomas Pausch
17 Jun 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Helen Mossop
17 Jun 2019	Reviewed	Reviewer Report - Aude Merdrignac
16 Jul 2019	Author responded	Author comments - Kazuto Shibuya
Resubmission - Version 4
16 Jul 2019	Submitted	Manuscript version 4
Publishing
18 Jul 2019	Editorially accepted
9 Aug 2019	Article published	10.1186/s13063-019-3595-x

Back to article page