From: Systematic review of the use of translated patient-reported outcome measures in cancer trials
Reference | No. of sites and (no. countries) examples of recruiting countries | Trial design | Diagnosis | Total N recruited into the study; White category/missing data n (%) | Total ethnic group n (%) (not including others) reported ethnic/others Categories n (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Armstrong et al. [19] | 17 (3) USA, Canada, and UK | Phase II RCT everolimus v sunitinib [19] | Patients with metastatic non-clear-cell renal cell carcinoma | 108; White 94 (87) | Non-white, 12 (11) Black 12 (11) |
Yao et al. [20] | 97 (25) Europe, Japan, South Korea | Phase III RCT everolimus v placebo | Patients with advanced progressive well-differentiated non-functional neuroendocrine tumours of the lung or gastrointestinal origin | 302; White 230 (76) | 50 (17) Asian 50 (17) Others 22 (7) |
Schöffski et al., primary paper [21]a) Hudgens et al., quality of life paper [22]b) | 110 (22) USA, Latin America, Europe, Asia, Australasia | Phase III RCT eribulin v dacarbazine [21] | Previously treated patients with advanced liposarcoma or leiomyosarcoma | 452a); White 330 (73)a) 442b) White 322 (73) Missing 63 (14) | 46 (10) Black/African-American 12 (3), Asian 34 (8), others or NA 76 (17)a) Black/African-American 12 (3)b) Japanese 1 (< 1) Chinese 3 (< 1) Other Asian 30 (7) Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander 1 (< 1) Others 10 (2) |
O’Shaughnessy et al. [23] | Approximately 65 North America, Europe, and Asia (exact numbers not provided) | Phase II RCT abiraterone acetate plus 5 mg prednisone, (AA) or AA with 25 mg exemestane (AAE) or 25 mg exemestane only (E) [23] | Post-menopausal women with oestrogen receptor–positive metastatic breast cancer | 297; 264 (89) Missing 24 (8) | 7 (2) Asian 7 (2), Black or African-American 0 (0), others 2 (1) |
Senan et al. [24] | 125 (21) East Asia, non-East Asia | Phase III RCT concurrent pemetrexed-cisplatin and thoracic radiation therapy (TRT) followed by consolidation pemetrexed v etoposide-cisplatin and TRT followed by nonpemetrexed doublet consolidation therapy [24] | Patients with stage IIIA/B unresectable non-squamous non-small-cell lung cancer | 598; White 421 (70) Missing 5 (1) | 172 (29) African 27 (5) East Asian 122 (20) Others (Hispanic/west Asian, Native American) 23 (4) |
Ryan et al. [25] | 113 (19) NS | Phase III RCT doxorubicin plus palifosfamide v doxorubicin plus placebo [25] | Patients with measurable metastatic soft tissue sarcoma | 447; White 371 (83) Unknown 21 (5) | 51 (11) Black 36 (8), Asian 15 (3) Others (category not identified) 4 (1) |
Verma et al. [26]a) Welslau et al. [27]b) | 213 (26) NS | Phase III | Women with HER2-positive advanced breast cancer previously treated with trastuzumab and a taxane | 991; White 732 (74) Missing 12 (1)a) | 230 (23) Asian 180 (18) Black 50 (5) Others (not defined) 17 (2)a) |
Escudier et al. [28] | Multi-centre (NS) NS | Phase IIIb RCT cross-over trial assessing preference for pazopanib v sunitinib [28] | Patients with metastatic renal cell carcinoma | 168; White 157 (99) Missing 9 (5) | Ethnicity Hispanic/Latino 16 (10) Not Hispanic/Latino 143 (85) Missing 9 (5) Race 2 (1) African-American/African heritage 1 (< 1) Asian 1 (< 1) |
UK only studies | |||||
 Beaver et al. [29] | 5 centres (1) North West, UK | Others RCT traditional hospital-based follow-up (HFU) v nurse-led telephone follow-up (TFU) [29] | Women with stage I endometrial cancer | 259; White 256 (99) | 3 (1) Indian 2 (< 1) Polish 1 (< 1) |
 Horne et al. [30] | Regional unit, (1) (UK) | Others Evaluation and development of website for patients with stem cell transplant [30] | Adults with allogeneic haematopoietic stem cell transplant | 52; White 23 (85) Missing 29 | 4 (8) Black British African 3 (11), Black British Caribbean 1 (4) (only Allinex access group data reported n = 27) |
 Molassiotis et al. [31] | Centres not stated (1) UK | Others RCT acupuncture v normal care for managing fatigue [31] | Women with breast cancer | 302; White = 283 (94) Missing 1 (< 1) | 18 (6) Black = 4 (1) Asian/Chinese = 9 (3) Mixed = 5 (2) |
 Molassiotis et al. [32] | 14 cancer units, (1) UK | Others RCT (to clarify if acupressure is effective in managing chemotherapy-related nausea and vomiting) [32] | Patients receiving chemotherapy for cancer | 500; Caucasian = 342 (68) Missing 145 (29) | 13 (3) Black = 3 (< 1) Asian/Chinese = 6 (1) Mixed = 4 (< 1) |
 Neal et al. [33] | 3 District General Hospitals (1) North Wales, UK | Others RCT (comparing self-report or researcher-completed tool measuring duration between first symptoms and cancer diagnosis) [33] | Patients with new primary diagnosis of cancer | 201; White British 164 (82) White 24 (12) White Irish 1 (< 1) Other white 9 (4) Missing 2 (1) | 1 (< 1) Indian 1 (< 1) |
 Jones et al. [34] | 2 NHS trusts and 1 hospice, (1) UK | Exploratory Patient preference RCT of advance care planning discussions with an independent mediator [34] | Patients attending oncology or hospice | 77; White 70 (92) Missing 1 (1) | 2 (3) Black Caribbean 2 (3) Others 4 (5) |