Skip to main content

Table 2 The reporting number and percentage for each item according to intervention in endorsing journal for reporting guidelines

From: Endorsement for improving the quality of reports on randomized controlled trials of traditional medicine journals in Korea: a systematic review

  

CONSORT-NPT

STRICTA (Total number of items = 17)

Intervention

Author (year)

Nunber of reported items

Percent (%)

Number of reported items

Percent (%)

Acupuncture (Total number of items = 37)

Park (2010) [21]

11

29.7

12

70.6

 

Lee (2010) [22]

11

29.7

11

64.7

 

Kim (2010) [23]

9

24.3

10

58.8

 

Kwon (2010) [24]

8

21.6

11

64.7

 

Joung (2010) [25]

10

27.0

9

52.9

 

Yoon (2010) [26]

9

24.3

14

82.4

 

Kim (2010) [27]

10

27.0

17

100.0

 

Chung (2010) [28]a b

21

56.8

9

52.9

 

Choi (2010) [29]

10

27.0

10

58.8

 

Jang (2010) [30]

12

32.4

9

52.9

 

Kim (2011) [31]b

13

35.1

9

52.9

 

Park (2011) [32]

12

32.4

10

58.8

 

Park (2011) [33]a

11

29.7

9

52.9

 

Lee (2011) [34]

9

24.3

11

64.7

 

Jeong (2011) [35]

9

24.3

9

52.9

 

Shin (2011) [36]

10

27.0

7

41.2

 

Lee (2011) [37]

12

32.4

9

52.9

 

Im (2011) [38]

10

27.0

9

52.9

 

Kim (2011) [39]

10

27.0

11

64.7

 

Han (2011) [40]

11

29.7

13

76.5

 

Kim (2012) [41]a

19

51.4

10

58.5

 

Kim (2012) [42]

11

29.7

9

52.9

 

Kim (2013) [43]

11

29.7

10

58.8

 

Kim (2013) [44]a

19

51.4

17

100.0

Moxibustion (Total number of items = 38)

Cho (2010) [45]

8

21.1

  
 

Lee (2012) [46]

9

23.7

-

-

 

Kim (2013) [47]b

12

31.6

-

-

Cupping (Total number of items = 38)

     
 

Kim (2013) [48]

9

23.7

-

-

Herbal medicine (Total number of items = 22)

     
 

Song (2012) [49]

17

77.2

-

-

  1. CONSORT-NPT: Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials with the non-pharmacological trials extension; STRICTA: Standards for Reporting Interventions in Clinical Trials of Acupuncture.
  2. Values are presented as number of reported items divided by the total number of items.
  3. Intervention on CONSORT-NPT included acupuncture, moxibustion and cupping intervention article besides herbal medicine intervention.
  4. aThis article included flow participant diagram.
  5. bThis article included trial registration or protocol information.