Skip to main content

Table 3 Methodological characteristics and key points

From: Antibiotic rotation strategies to reduce antimicrobial resistance in Gram-negative bacteria in European intensive care units: study protocol for a cluster-randomized crossover controlled trial

Study design feature

Advantages

Disadvantages

Remarks

Cluster allocation

Prevents allocation bias

Susceptible to case mix fluctuations in time

Prevented by adequate intervention period length

Prevents between-intervention correlation as compared with individual randomization

Creates cluster correlation of outcomes

Will be accounted for in analysis

Open treatment design

Transparency in patient treatment

Different treatment adherence between different preferred antibiotics

Does not differ between interventions

Pre-intervention control period

Enables comparison with standard care. Enables time trend analysis for time-dependent increase in prevalence

No control group parallel in time

Comparable parallel groups/intensive care units (ICUs) not available, are expected to have higher heterogeneity in ICU characteristics than within-ICU comparisons using a crossover design

Crossover

Intervention comparison within ICUs equals out differences that influence outcome

Increases trial time-span and effect of baseline resistance increases over time

Addressed with time-trend analysis using pre-intervention control period