Study design feature | Advantages | Disadvantages | Remarks |
---|---|---|---|
Cluster allocation | Prevents allocation bias | Susceptible to case mix fluctuations in time | Prevented by adequate intervention period length |
Prevents between-intervention correlation as compared with individual randomization | Creates cluster correlation of outcomes | Will be accounted for in analysis | |
Open treatment design | Transparency in patient treatment | Different treatment adherence between different preferred antibiotics | Does not differ between interventions |
Pre-intervention control period | Enables comparison with standard care. Enables time trend analysis for time-dependent increase in prevalence | No control group parallel in time | Comparable parallel groups/intensive care units (ICUs) not available, are expected to have higher heterogeneity in ICU characteristics than within-ICU comparisons using a crossover design |
Crossover | Intervention comparison within ICUs equals out differences that influence outcome | Increases trial time-span and effect of baseline resistance increases over time | Addressed with time-trend analysis using pre-intervention control period |