Skip to main content

Table 2 Bias assessment of included studies

From: Is there excess mortality in women screened with mammography: a meta-analysis of non-breast cancer mortality

Clinical trial

Randomization

Classification of the cause

Post-randomization

Contamination bias

Compliance bias study

  

of death

exclusions

control group

group

UK Age Trial [17, 18]

Low risk of bias

Low risk of bias

Low risk of bias

No risk of bias

No risk of bias

Goteborg [7, 8, 19, 20]

High risk of bias

Low risk of bias

Low risk of bias

No risk of bias

No risk of bias

Malmö 1 [8, 21]

Low risk of bias

Unclear risk of bias

Low risk of bias

Low risk of bias

+

Malmö 2 [7, 22]

High risk of bias

Low risk of bias

Unclear risk of bias

No risk of bias

No risk of bias

Stockholm [8, 23]

High risk of bias

Unclear risk of bias

Unclear risk of bias

No risk of bias

No risk of bias

Canada 1 [24, 27]

Low risk of bias

Low risk of bias

Low risk of bias

+

No risk of bias

Canada 2 [25, 26]

Low risk of bias

Low risk of bias

Low risk of bias

+

No risk of bias

2 Swedish counties [2830]

High risk of bias

High risk of bias

High risk of bias

No risk of bias

No risk of bias

New York [3133]

High risk of bias

Low risk of bias

Unclear risk of bias

Low risk of bias

+

Edinburgh [34]

High risk of bias

Low risk of bias

High risk of bias

No risk of bias

+