Skip to main content

Table 2 Characters of RCTs of different interventions (Chinese journals VS foreign journals)

From: Quality assessment of reporting of randomization, allocation concealment, and blinding in traditional chinese medicine RCTs: A review of 3159 RCTs identified from 260 systematic reviews

  

Number of RCTs

Adequate randomization

methods

Adequate allocation

concealment

Adequate blinding

Classification

Chinese

Foreign

Total

Chinese

Foreign

Total

Chinese

Foreign

Total

Chinese

Foreign

Total

     

(%)

(%)

(%)

(%)

(%)

(%)

(%)

(%)

(%)

Drug

Chinese standardized remedies

1135

42

1177

140(12)

13(31)

153(13)

32(3)

13(31)

45(4)

148(13)

36(86)

184(16)

 

Chinese medicine extracts

241

107

348

7(3)

26(24)

33(9)

3(1)

30(28)

33(9)

12(5)

37(35)

49(14)

 

Single herb

100

67

167

3(3)

9(13)

12(7)

0(0)

5(7)

5(3)

5(5)

62(93)

67(40)

 

Individualized prescription

562

13

575

41(7)

4(31)

45(8)

1(0)

4(31)

5(1)

24(4)

10(77)

34(6)

 

Mixture

115

20

135

4(3)

0(0)

4(3)

0(0)

0(0)

0(0)

10(9)

19(95)

29(21)

 

Unclear

141

3

144

4(3)

0(0)

4(3)

3(2)

1(33)

4(3)

3(2)

0(0)

3(2)

 

Total

2294

252

2546

199(9)

52(21)

251(10)

39(2)

53(21)

92(4)

202(9)

164(65)

366(14)

Non-drug

Acupuncture

263

219

482

37(14)

69(32)

106(22)

17(6)

73(33)

90(19)

49(19)

149(68)

198(41)

 

Massage

23

108

131

3(13)

21(19)

24(18)

0(0)

25(23)

25(19)

1(4)

36(33)

37(28)

 

Total

286

327

613

40(14)

90(28)

130(21)

17(6)

98(30)

115(19)

50(17)

185(57)

235(38)

 

χ2

     

59.99

  

185.10

  

184.11

 

P

     

0.000

  

0.000

  

0.000

  1. * Comparison of drugs with non-drugs