Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of included articles (n = 303) and RCTs described in these articles (n = 319)*

From: Dealing with heterogeneity of treatment effects: is the literature up to the challenge?

Characteristic

Articles Represented

# RCTs Included

Journal of publication

  

   Annals

30 (10)

30 (9)

   BMJ

43 (14)

47 (15)

   JAMA

45 (15)

50 (16)

   Lancet

97 (32)

101 (32)

   NEJM

88 (29)

91 (29)

Year of publication

  

   1994

86 (28)

91 (29)

   1999

102 (34)

106 (33)

   2004

115 (38)

122 (38)

Medical condition under study

  

   Cardiovascular

69 (23)

74 (23)

   Infectious Disease

62 (20)

70 (22)

   Cancer

41 (14)

42 (13)

   Psychiatry/Neurology

25 (8)

25 (8)

   Other

106 (35)

108 (34)

First author's study region

  

   North America

115 (38)

121 (38)

   Other

188 (62)

198 (62)

Study design

  

   Parallel

-

304 (95)

   Crossover

-

15 (5)

Analysis reported

  

   HTE analysis

-

92 (29)

   Subgroup without statistical comparison

-

88 (28)

   None

-

139 (44)

Sample size

 

262 (101 – 708)

 

-

[6–41,000]

  1. Abbreviations: RCTs, randomized controlled trials; BMJ, British Medical Journal; JAMA, Journal of the American Medical Association; NEJM, New England Journal of Medicine; HTE, heterogeneity of treatment effects.
  2. *Discrete data are expressed as No. (%); continuous values are presented as median (inter-quartile range) [range].