Skip to main content

Table 2 Summary statistics at baseline and day 28 expressed as mean and between-group effect sizes

From: Acupuncture for the treatment of phantom limb syndrome in lower limb amputees: a randomised controlled feasibility study

Outcome measure

Group

Baseline mean (±95 % CI)

Between-group effect size (Cohen’s d)

Day 28 mean (±95 % CI)

Between-group effect size (Cohen’s d)

Number of participants who provided complete data

Acupuncture

8

 

7

 

Usual care

7

 

5

 

NRS average pain

Acupuncture

5.44 (3.90–6.98)

0.00

2.75 (0.31–5.19)

0.64

Usual care

5.43 (3.75–7.11)

4.43 (2.37–6.49)

NRS worst pain

Acupuncture

8.00 (6.21–9.79)

0.38

4.00 (0.40–7.60)

0.69

Usual care

7.29 (5.80–8.77)

6.29 (4.54–8.03)

SF-MPQ-2

Acupuncture

2.55 (1.70–3.40)

0.21

1.06 (0.13–2.24)

0.46

Usual care

2.85 (1.22–4.47)

1.89 (0.07–3.85)

HADS anxiety

Acupuncture

6.38 (2.75–10.00)

0.29

5.25 (1.97–8.53)

0.10

Usual care

5.29 (2.33–8.24)

4.86 (1.38–8.34)

HADS depression

Acupuncture

6.63 (3.34–9.91)

0.35

0.35 5.75 (1.35–10.15)

0.12

Usual care

5.14 (0.99–9.29

5.14 (0.99–9.29)

PSS-10

Acupuncture

15.25 (10.90–19.60)

0.31

11.63 (5.43–17.82)

0.48

Usual care

17.28 (10.11–24.46)

15.57 (7.35–23.79)

ISI

Acupuncture

13.50 (5.96–21.04)

0.49

8.50 (1.65–15.35)

0.14

Usual care

9.14 (0.93–17.35)

7.42 (0.61–14.24)

EQ-5D-5 L mobility

Acupuncture

4.88 (4.58–5.17)

0.00

3.75 (2.88–4.62)

0.47

Usual care

4.88 (4.58–5.17)

4.29 (3.13–5.45)

EQ-5D-5 L self care

Acupuncture

1.75 (1.16–2.34)

0.24

1.63 (1.00–2.25)

0.09

Usual care

1.57 (0.84–2.30)

1.57 (1.08–2.07)

EQ-5D-5 L usual activities

Acupuncture

3.75 (2.68–4.82)

0.45

2.88 (2.18–3.57)

0.84

Usual care

4.29 (3.26–5.31)

3.71 (2.69–4.74)

EQ-5D-5 L pain-discomfort

Acupuncture

3.50 (2.87–4.13)

1.24

2.88 (2.18–3.57)

0.44

Usual care

2.71 (2.26–3.17)

2.57 (2.08–3.07)

EQ-5D-5 L anxiety/depression

Acupuncture

2.00 (1.11–2.89)

0.46

2.00 (1.23–2.77)

0.50

Usual care

1.57 (0.84–2.30)

1.57 (0.84–2.30)

EQ-5D-5 L health today

Acupuncture

63.13 (46.41–79.84)

0.21

74.63 (58.49–90.76)

0.15

Usual care

67.14 (50.29–84.00)

77.14 (63.05–91.23)

PGIC

Acupuncture

  

5.71 (4.23–7.20)

1.27

Usual care

  

3.20 (0.37–6.03)

  1. CI confidence interval, EQ-5D-5 L EuroQol-5 dimensions, HADS Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale, ISI Insomnia Severity Index, NRS numerical rating scale, PGIC Patient Global Impression of Change, PSS-10 Perceived Stress Scale 10-item, SF-MPQ-2 Short Form McGill Pain Questionnaire 2